| Player | All-American Season(s) | Organization | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ed Mullen | 1933-34 | Chuck Taylor Converse |
| 2 | Dave Quabius | 1938-39 | Chuck Taylor Converse |
| 3 | Terry Rand | 1955-56 | All-Catholic |
| 4 | Don Kojis | 1959-60 | Catholic Digest |
| 1960-61 | Chuck Taylor Converse; Catholic Digest | ||
| 5 | George Thompson | 1968-69 | Chuck Taylor Converse |
| 6 | Dean Meminger | 1969-70 | Chuck Taylor Converse; NEA |
| 1970-71 | Associated Press; Converse; Helms; NABC; NEA; Sporting News; UPI; USBWA | ||
| 7 | Jim Chones | 1971-72 | Associated Press; Converse; UPI |
| 8 | Bob Lackey | 1971-72 | Helms |
| 9 | Maurice Lucas | 1973-74 | Converse (2nd Team) |
| 10 | Maurice (Bo) Ellis | 1974-75 | Independent; Converse (2nd Team) |
| 1976-77 | Converse; Basketball Weekly; Associated Press (2nd Team) | ||
| 11 | Lloyd Walton | 1974-75 | Independent |
| 1975-76 | Independent; Basketball Weekly (2nd Team) | ||
| 12 | Earl Tatum | 1975-76 | Associated Press; Basketball Weekly; Helms; Independent; UPI; USBWA; Converse (2nd Team) |
| 13 | Butch Lee | 1976-77 | Basketball Weekly; Converse; Associated Press (2nd Team) |
| 1977-78 | Associated Press; Basketball Weekly; Citizen Savings; Converse; NABC; Sporting News; UPI; USBWA | ||
| 14 | Jerome Whitehead | 1977-78 | Converse; NABC |
| 15 | Sam Worthen | 1978-79 | Basketball Weekly (2nd Team) |
| 1979-80 | Medalist; Playboy; Sport; USBWA; Basketball Weekly (2nd Team); UPI (3rd Team) | ||
| 16 | Glenn "Doc" Rivers | 1981-82 | Converse |
| 1982-83 | API; UPI (Honorable Mention) | ||
| 17 | Tony Smith | 1989-90 | Basketball Weekly; Sporting News; UPI; Associated Press (Honorable Mention) |
| 18 | Tony Miller | 1991-92 | Basketball Weekly, All-Freshman Team (5th Team) |
| 19 | Roney Eford | 1992-93 | Basketball Weekly, All-Freshman Team (5th Team) |
| 20 | Jim McIlvaine | 1993-94 | Associated Press (Honorable Mention) |
| 21 | Dwyane Wade | 2001-02 | Associated Press (Honorable Mention) |
| 2002-03 | Associated Press; Sporting News; USBWA; Basketball Times; ESPN.com; FOXSPORTS.com; CNNSI/com (1st Team) | ||
| 22 | Travis Diener | 2004-05 | Associated Press (Honorable Mention) |
| 23 | Dominic James | 2006-07 | Associated Press (Honorable Mention) |